Andrea Karshan's Articles, Crown Heights, Voting, Women's Rights

Crown Heights Jewish Women Should Be Able To Vote In CH Jewish Elections-But They Aren’t

In Chabad Crown Heights, the Jewish community is holding elections, and women aren’t allowed to vote. 


Elections are being held in June in Chabad Crown Heights for the Vaad Hakohol and the Crown Heights Jewish Community Council for the first time in 8 years. The Vaad Hakohol is a religious organization in Crown Heights that deals with Kashrut. And the Crown Heights Community Council is a secular organization in Crown Heights that is partly government funded. The Crown Heights Community Council deals with food assistance, housing, medical insurance, community relations, and other things.


When I found out about this election, I was excited. And I thought to myself how can I get involved. But then I was told that women aren’t allowed to vote. I am a woman who lives alone. So my household will be not be spoken for in the election. The leaders of these organizations don’t just serve the men in the community. They serve the women too. Women should be able to vote also. We should have a voice in choosing the people who represent us in the community. In general elections, whether it be for city council, president or any other political position, Jewish women in Chabad Crown Heights are encouraged to vote, especially for candidates who local Chabad community leaders have endorsed. So forbidding Jewish women to vote in Crown Heights only applies to this election.

This policy of women not voting in these elections completely excludes unmarried, divorced and widowed women from the voting process. As for married women and women living with their fathers, the assumption is that everyone in the household would vote the same way. But perhaps the wife and husband or father and daughter would vote differently. Therefore, they should have their voice when it comes to voting. Any Jewish resident of Crown Heights over the age of 18 male or female should have a vote.

After hearing that women cannot vote in the upcoming Vaad Hakohol and Crown Heights Community Council elections, I went to talk to someone at the Crown Heights Community Council about it. One thing he told me was that the Crown Heights Rabbonim believed that based on Jewish history that only men voted, Jewish law was that women could not vote in this type of election. I replied to him what if we based American law on American history that only white men had rights and blacks and women didn’t? He couldn’t answer me. The Torah may be timeless. But these policies are definitely outdated.

The representative from the Crown Heights Community also told me that women voting policies were voted on by the community (men and women, and I believe that’s the only time that women voted) following a lawsuit in the 1990s. And the community voted that men only should vote. But the CrownHeights Rabbonim before the vote advised the community to vote that only men should vote.

I think as long as the Rabbonim are advising people to think this way about women voting in these elections, it is hard for people to publicly go against the Rabbonim. But I think privately many Lubavitchers in Crown Heights are for women voting in these elections.

This matter now lies in the hands of the Crown Heights Rabbonim. It is up to them to decide whether or not women will be able to vote or not. 
I hope that now years later since the 1990s the minds of the Rabbonim have changed a little, and they will understand that women’s voices are a very important part of this community. And that women should have the right to vote in the upcoming Vaad Hakohol and Crown Heights Jewish Community Council elections. The Rabbonim should be encouraged by Jewish leaders and the community to decide in favor of women voting. The Crown Heights Jewish community should speak up and tell the Rabbonim that this issue is important to them and that they want women to be able to vote. 

Also published in the Bklyner

One Comment

  1. Ag

    Wow, I’m horrified to learn of this type of gender discrimination, especially from Chabad whose former leader, the Lubavitcher Rebbe Schneerson, was very pro-women learning and respected their intellect. Those who live in the community and see the importance in pursuing women’s voting rights should act on this. I can’t even think of one Halacha that would prohibit women from voting for leaders in their community. It’s not as if heavens forbid they’re being asked to serve as an “Ed”. B’hazlacha!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: